My first favorite fairy tale had to be The Little Mermaid. I used to call it My Little Mermaid, getting it confused with my little ponies. But to me it made sense: she had red hair like me. I did, in fact, own the video, and I knew pretty much all of the dialogue and songs by heart. Then there is the fact that my mother swears that I broke our television set by watching this movie, and only this movie while I was down and out with the chicken pox when I was four.
But alas, I was a fickle elementary school child, for I found a new favorite fairytale when I was in first grade. I saw Beauty and the Beast when I was six, and I was completely hooked. Here was a girl who read incessantly (I hadn’t begun my book obsession yet. We’ll just look at it as things to come.) She had her own mind, and was able to throw a nasty boy into a mud puddle.
The animation was beautiful. The characters were fun. It was exciting. I couldn’t find anything to complain about.
About seven years later, I was in Mrs. Karns’s English class, and I found the book Beauty, by Robin McKinley, sitting on her bookshelf. It was a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, where Beauty is even more strong willed, and rather plain looking. I was, I freely admit, an awkward and plain middle school student who worshiped books and felt a bit out of place. How could I resist a book detailing a girl just like this, only with magical element of my favorite fairytale worked in. I snatched up the book, and only made it to chapter three.
Something that you have to understand about McKinley’s writing is that she slowly paints you a picture of her characters. You need to give her time to get something on the canvas that will make sense to you, the reader. But it’s worth waiting for. I tried the book two more times, and finally made it past the first chapters of exposition. Then I was stuck. I’m pretty sure this was one of the books that I was almost caught furtively reading under the desk during math class.
McKinley takes liberties with her story. The most obvious is of course that Beauty is not beautiful (though this is explained). The sisters, who in the original fairytale are greedy and vain are sweet and thoughtful, if not always the most pragmatic.
The best part of the story is the development of a relationship between Beauty and the Beast. One of the reasons that I loved this fairy tale so much was that it wasn’t a love at first sight story. They had to get to know each other. McKinley makes sure that this isn’t lost in her story. Beauty still gets annoyed and freaked out by things, as one would expect of a girl snatched from all familiarity. But the characters move towards love and commitment, rather than just leaping there.
My only complaint is the ending. It’s pretty much by the book with a few added elements that didn’t seem necessary. However, these small aspects of the story are barely worth noting when one remembers that McKinley has taken an already haunting and lovely fairytale, and created an even more wonderful novel.
Next, I’ll try to look at Rose Daughter, and get better at this sort of thing.